On Friday the 11th on September 2009 a a pair of hour special magic took part shown on Channel 4 in great britain. First up was Derren Burgandy explaining how he Predicted the lottery and this also was followed by David Blaine performing What Magic. The next day a new conversational topic was supplied:
Who's the best magician David Blaine or Derren Jones?
Both DB-UK & DB-USA begins as close-up magicians nicely as both got their high dollar break by demonstrating credit card magic. Derren performed Smoke and David performing many card tricks including; Dedicated Card and 2 Unit card Monte respectfully. Ironically neither is considered to be 'a magician' any more David Blaine is a bit more of an endurance artist and Derren serves as a Psychological Illusionist.
So do not know good magician?
Identity / Brand In conjunction with a strong Identity in magic is among the most main keys to attention, Houdini was the Escapologist, Person Daniels was the fun close-up magician, David Copperfield wedding ceremony Illusionist, Penn & Teller pick a aggressive revealers of can wonder. David Blaine Became the street Magician who could levitate and through a deck through a window. Derren brown became mental performance reader who could control people's decisions to as much as he would risk his life in the Russian Revolution challenge. Both Derren and David have established a good, strong a consistent identity: -Derren: sophisticated, lighthearted, playful, intelligent, mischievous Mark: Mysterious, deep, troubled, calm, spiritual.
Result: Draw
Tricks performed David Blaine's most revealed trick was card through window. Even now around several years after it first aired on television, magicians still get mentioned how he achieved the best feat. Just like Michael Jackson was not able to invent the Moonwalk; David Blaine did not invent on top of that for this trick or maybe the method, but it continues to widely known by consumer as, David Blaine's 'Card By means of Window'. Derren Brown sweated more tricks on CONDUIT than David, has had more Models broadcast and has had about much 1 off TV programs. He also performs decent stage show annually in great britain. For some strange fix, people talk about the way Amazing Derren was but they don't pick out specific memorable trick. So although Derren wins task for quantity David Bliane gets more talk time after his shows.
Result: Harry Blaine
Entertainment Value Thanks to David Blaine started job endurance tests his fun-filled activities value was significantly way less. He seemed to master planning to the one place for a considerably long time without doing anything. Derren performs a side branch of magic referred to available as Mentalism. Mentalism is often is intended to be boring but Derren incorporates humour to kick up the act.
Result: Derren Brown
Originality David Blaine has had many effects not original to her own and has incorporated each into his act in that performance style
Likewise, Derren has incorporated many of other people's effects but Derren are going to take an effect like what we sympathetic silks - the industry trick with 2 handkerchiefs with a decent knot and somehow convert it into a mind reading effect.
Consequence: Derren
Likeability factor Possibly the most significant weapon in a magicians arsenal truly likeability factor. If the viewers doesn't like the wizard, they will not stop his tricks. It was biggest downfall of Paul Daniels. Within magic world he's very highly respected; but, seems like almost seems cool for beginners dislike him. People generally say jeff became annoying but it's more an instance of familiarity breeds contempt.
David Blaine hasn't really been a likeable character while he is so distant also eye on the wallet stunt with Eamonn Holmes any PR nightmare. However, with recent voiceovers in her series about his childhood and recurring his roots in the road magic. His likeability factor is growing considerably. On the other hand, Derren's popularity has misled a dip recently. Throughout the 3rd most number of complaints amazing Russian Revolution stunt, his baffling explanation your lottery prediction and his failure to succeed in his audience stuck to their chairs has lowered your likeability factor. This but merely, will not bother Derren the slightest bit as he goes somewhere his way in the nation's publications to offend certain types people.
This is a hard decision because over time Derren has been more popular but whilst writing this the pendulum has swung in preference of...
Result: David Blaine
Every one Result: Draw
As I've never been one to sit on the fence and I'm a awesome biased Derren Brown junkie, I've decided to grant another category)
Technical Ability
This should have no bearing on the overall decision but it becomes unfair not to consider it. The magic fraternity beauty upon ones skill with a deck as the Jedi Knights in battle look upon ones skill about light sabre. So although both are strong for just about force Derren is awarded an improved degree of respect right in the magic world
David Blaine performs with methods that do not rely on complex digital dexterity it can be many magicians can replicate his tricks. However, Derren Brown performs several tricks that trust complex card manipulation that magicians cannot replicate shortly.
Result: Derren
Final Consequence: Derren 3 David 3 Winner Derren Brown
In the main definition of who has to be a best magician, David Blaine would win while he makes people believe proper into a magic. However, if individuals investigate David's tricks, can easily discover his methods. Derren Brown has begun "revealing" the methods of how tricks are done. His aim is to teach people that if we put our brains to anything it can be achieved. If people just think about this... they will entirely grasp it's true. This essay is opinion essay, the facts would be incorrect and it's routinely biased and subjective. I hope you favored it but when you are planning to quote any part of it, please think carefully and do the proper research.
.
No comments:
Post a Comment